Power outages and backup power
Natural Gas vs Propane Generator - Which Fuel Fits Your House, and Where Gasoline Fits
Updated October 17, 2026 - 5 min read - Rainy Day Plan
The short answer
Choosing a natural gas vs propane generator comes down to what your house has and how long your outages run. Natural gas feeds a standby unit from the street for as long as gas reaches your meter, with nothing to store. Propane runs a standby from a tank or a portable from cylinders, and it keeps. Gasoline, the third fuel, runs a portable from cans you store and rotate.
Match the fuel to your house
| Your house | The fuel that fits | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A gas line to the meter, and long or frequent outages | Natural gas, in a standby | Nothing to store or pour. It runs while gas reaches the meter. |
| A gas line, but gas has been shut off in your area after past disasters | Propane, or natural gas with a plan B | A full tank on your own property doesn't depend on the street. |
| No gas line, long outages, or nobody at home who can pour fuel in a storm | Propane: a tank for a standby, or cylinders for a portable if someone can roll it out and swap them | It's stored as a liquid in a sealed tank, so you fill it in the off-season and leave it. |
| No gas line, outages of a day or two, someone who can carry cans | Gasoline, in a portable | Easy to buy before a storm, and running in blocks of a few hours keeps the cans few. The cost is a rotation chore, below. |
| No spot outdoors at least 20 feet from the house | No engine generator. A battery power station | Every fuel makes carbon monoxide. Sizing a battery is on portable power station. |
What three days of each fuel takes
Natural gas: nothing to store, two things to check
You don't stock it and you don't pour it. Two checks decide whether it works for you:
- The meter and the line have to carry the generator at full load plus the furnace, the water heater and everything else on gas. The utility tells you whether yours can. The worksheet for that call and the two permits are on natural gas generator for home.
- The gas can stop. If you ever smell gas, get out and call 911 from a distance. If you turn the gas off in an emergency, a qualified professional turns it back on. Until then, the generator sits dark.
Propane: about a third more gallons than gasoline
For the same work, figure roughly 1.3 gallons of propane for every gallon of gasoline, an estimate from the energy in each. If your generator's spec sheet lists a propane run time, go by that instead. What you get back is time. Propane keeps in its sealed tank, and there's no 30-day clock on it. A portable's cylinders carry a date and live outdoors, not in the house or the garage. The hours from one cylinder, the count for three days and the date rules are on propane generator for home.
Gasoline: 36 to 54 gallons nonstop, far less in blocks
A portable typically burns half to three-quarters of a gallon each hour. Three days nonstop is 36 to 54 gallons. Run it in blocks of a few hours and that shrinks to what a few cans hold. Your model's own number, the block plans and the can rotation are in how much gas does a generator use. The catch with gasoline is the clock. Untreated, it should be used within 30 days, so a gasoline plan is a chore that never quite ends: you date the cans, pour them into the car on time and fill them again.
The same standby unit makes less power on natural gas
A standby unit built for both gases usually puts out less on natural gas than on propane, and its spec sheet lists a rating for each. The gap differs from one model to the next, so read both lines instead of the big number in the ad, and check which fuel that number belongs to. The fuel doesn't change how many watts you need. Add those up on what size generator do I need, then hold the total against the rating for the fuel you'll burn. A list that only just fits under the propane figure can come up short once the unit runs on gas from the meter.
What you pay for with each fuel
Natural gas is billed after you burn it, from your meter readings. What the generator burns lands on the same bill as your heating and hot water, so a long outage shows up on a later bill, and there's nothing to buy ahead.
Propane is paid for before the outage. A dealer delivers it to a tank you rent from that dealer or own outright. Most dealers won't fill a tank another dealer owns, while owning yours lets you compare dealers but leaves the upkeep to you. Before you sign, ask about pre-pay and fixed-price plans, add-on fees such as trip and after-hours charges, and how much notice a delivery needs.
To compare the two at your address, take the generator's fuel use from its spec sheet for the load you plan to run, then price those hours at your utility's gas rate and at a propane dealer's quote.
"Gas" can mean two different machines
At the pump, gas is gasoline. At the meter, it's natural gas. A gasoline generator is almost always a portable on wheels that you fill from a can. A natural gas generator is a standby unit on a pad, piped to the meter, that starts by itself.
Propane sits between them. Home standby units run on natural gas or propane, and portables usually run on gasoline or propane, some on both.
Diesel and dual fuel
Diesel is less common at home, and some cities limit it. San Jose, for one, doesn't allow diesel for a hard-wired home standby generator. Ask your building department before you shop. Whatever you store, the local fire department sets how much and where.
A portable that burns both gasoline and propane takes some pressure off the cans. Burn propane once the cans run low, and let the gasoline go into the car on its rotation date instead of sitting for a season.
Cleaner fuel, same carbon monoxide
Propane and natural gas burn cleaner than gasoline, but carbon monoxide comes out of every small engine, whatever it burns. Standby units on natural gas or propane make it too.
- A portable runs outdoors only, at least 20 feet from the house, with its exhaust aimed away from windows, doors and vents. It never runs in a garage, basement, crawlspace or shed, and not on a porch or in a carport.
- For a standby unit, ask for a spot at least 25 feet from every window, door and vent, soffit vents included. Have the installer measure that before the pad is poured.
- Any home with a generator needs a battery-powered carbon monoxide alarm on every level and outside the bedrooms. When one sounds, get everyone outside, then call 911.
- Generator power gets into the house wiring only by way of a transfer switch or interlock installed by a licensed electrician, never a wall outlet or the panel.
Sources
Every number in this article comes from these public sources, and we checked each one before it went up.
- UF/IFAS Extension - Portable generators, know watt's right and wrong
- EIA - Energy units and calculators explained
- Maine Department of Environmental Protection - Tips for handling gasoline
- DOE Alternative Fuels Data Center - Propane fuel basics
- Utah Be Ready - Generator
- Ready.gov - Life-saving skills toolkit, gas shut-off
- City of San Jose - Standby generator permit requirements, updated April 2026
- CPSC staff - Stationary generators, the carbon monoxide poisoning hazard and recommendations for mitigation, June 2025
- CPSC - What to know about generators and carbon monoxide, 2022
- CDC - Carbon monoxide poisoning basics
- Kentucky Public Service Commission - Utility meter guide
- Wisconsin DATCP - Propane buying tips for consumers




































